Crash-Rated Bollards: Protecting Public Spaces During Social Unrest

Understanding Social Unrest and Its Impact

Periods of civil unrest challenge not only social order but also the safety and functionality of the spaces we rely on every day. For urban planners, security professionals, and public officials, understanding the root causes and potential consequences of unrest is a critical first step in designing resilient communities. This section explores how social and political tensions manifest in public spaces—and why protective infrastructure is an essential part of safeguarding people and property when unrest occurs.

What is social unrest?

Social unrest is a breakdown in social order driven by widespread dissatisfaction. It often takes the form of protests, strikes, or riots, and can range from peaceful gatherings to violent disruptions. Civil disorders may involve acts of property damage or violence intended to provoke institutional change. While some civil disorders are politically motivated, others focus more on crimes against property rather than deliberately harming individuals. Understanding the nature of social unrest is crucial for developing effective strategies to manage and mitigate its potential negative impacts on public safety and infrastructure.

Key Causes of Protests and Demonstrations

Social unrest arises from multiple factors and complex societal pressures that create tension within society. Economic inequality stands as a primary driver, with large gaps between rich and poor generating feelings of injustice and frustration among disadvantaged groups. When people lack access to basic needs, the likelihood of civil unrest increases significantly.

Political oppression also contributes to civil unrest. When citizens feel their voices are suppressed, they may resort to protests as their only means of expression. Social and ethnic discrimination based on race, religion, gender and other factors also creates deep societal divisions that can spark protests against inequalities.

Other significant causes include:

• Unemployment and economic instability, which breed frustration and disillusionment
• Political corruption that erodes public trust in institutions
• Rapid social change and cultural shifts that create uncertainty and anxiety
• Environmental degradation affecting access to natural resources
• Globalization and technological changes that disrupt traditional ways of life

These factors rarely operate in isolation; rather, they interact and compound each other, creating complex conditions that can ultimately trigger widespread social unrest.

Recent U.S. examples:

• George Floyd protests (2020): The largest in U.S. history, sparking global demonstrations.
• January 6, 2021 Capitol attack: Violent protest against the certification of election results.
• Portland and Seattle unrest (2020): Long-term protests that led to property damage and deployment of the National Guard.
• University protests (2024): Demonstrations sparked by the Israel-Hamas conflict, underscoring the impact of global events on local unrest.

During unrest, critical infrastructure may be vandalized or disabled. Demonstrations can block emergency routes, while vehicle ramming incidents present growing dangers in dense pedestrian areas. These threats demand both strategic planning and protective physical infrastructure.

How unrest threatens public infrastructure and pedestrian safety

Social unrest poses significant threats to both public infrastructure and pedestrian safety through various mechanisms. During civil disorders, public facilities such as government buildings, transportation systems, and utilities often become targets for vandalism or destruction, disrupting essential services and requiring costly repairs.

One of the most concerning threats during periods of unrest is vehicle ramming attacks, which have become increasingly common at protests. Between May and June 2020 alone, there were reports of 50 vehicle-ramming incidents at protests against police violence, with at least 18 categorized as deliberate attacks. These incidents represent a serious danger to pedestrians gathered in demonstration areas, as vehicles can cause mass casualties in densely packed crowds.

The risks extend beyond intentional attacks to include:

• Accidental collisions due to confusion and chaos during protests
• Damage to protective barriers and security infrastructure
• Fires and explosions targeting buildings or vehicles
• Disruption of emergency response capabilities when infrastructure is compromised

These threats highlight the critical need for robust physical security measures and strategic urban planning to protect both infrastructure and human lives during periods of social unrest.

Challenges in Crowd Management During Civil Unrest

Without proper control, large crowds can become chaotic—raising risks of stampedes, confrontations, and opportunistic crime. Law enforcement faces challenges distinguishing peaceful demonstrators from agitators, especially with limited communication and response mobility.

The psychological dynamics of crowds can also lead to behavior escalation, where individuals may act in ways they normally wouldn’t due to group influence, anonymity, and emotional contagion.

Property damage and looting often occur when crowds lack direction or containment, resulting in significant economic losses for businesses and communities. Additionally, unmanaged crowds create opportunities for bad actors to exploit the chaos for criminal activities or to deliberately incite violence. The presence of counter-protesters can further complicate crowd dynamics, potentially leading to direct confrontations between opposing groups.

The importance of planning and situational awareness

Effective management of civil unrest requires comprehensive planning and heightened situational awareness by both authorities and participants. Law enforcement agencies must develop detailed plans well in advance of potential unrest, ensuring all city government departments can work together in a coordinated response. These plans should include clear protocols for crowd control, communication strategies, and resource allocation to prevent situations from escalating.

Situational awareness—the ability to perceive, comprehend, and predict events in the surrounding environment—is crucial for public safety officials managing civil unrest. This awareness enables:

• Early detection of potential threats and prevention of incidents
• Proactive decision-making based on evolving dynamics
• Optimal resource allocation to areas of greatest need
• De-escalation of tensions before violence erupts

Crash-Rated Bollards as a Public Safety Solution

Crash-rated bollards are designed to stop vehicles on impact, providing a critical defense against both accidental collisions and intentional vehicle ramming attacks. They undergo rigorous testing to meet ASTM standards to verify their stopping power and penetration resistance. Unlike decorative bollards, crash-rated ones are engineered for real-world threats.

How they work: ASTM Ratings, Vehicle Mitigation

Crash-rated bollards function by absorbing and redistributing the kinetic energy from vehicle impacts through their material composition and foundation systems. When a vehicle collides with a properly installed crash-rated bollard, the energy is transferred through the bollard’s structure and into its reinforced foundation, effectively stopping the vehicle’s forward momentum. 

The effectiveness of crash-rated bollards is measured through standardized testing protocols, primarily those established by the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM). The two main ASTM standards for bollard testing are:

1. ASTM F2656: High-speed crash ratings
   • M30: Stops a 15,000-lb vehicle at 30 mph
   • M50: Stops a 15,000-lb vehicle at 50 mph
2. ASTM F3016: Low-speed storefront protection
   • S10: Stops a 5,000-pound vehicle at 10 mph
   • S20: Stops a 5,000-pound vehicle at 20 mph
   • S30: Stops a 5,000-pound vehicle at 30 mph

Each rating also includes a penetration designation (P1, P2, P3) indicating how far the vehicle travels beyond the bollard after impact, with P1 being less than 3.3 feet of penetration. These standardized ratings allow security planners to select appropriate bollard systems based on specific threat assessments and site requirements.

Key use cases:

• Plazas and pedestrian areas: Prevent vehicle intrusions during protests or events.
• Government buildings: High-value targets that demand strong, visible deterrents.
• Retail storefronts: Increasingly vulnerable to crashes and “ram-raid” burglaries.

How Bollards Contribute to Perimeter Security

Bollards play a crucial role in comprehensive perimeter security strategies by establishing clear boundaries that protect vulnerable areas while maintaining appropriate access control. When properly designed and implemented, perimeter security measures including bollards help deter potential attacks, deny unauthorized access, and delay breach attempts, giving security personnel time to respond.

In high-risk areas, bollards serve as the first line of defense against vehicle-based threats by:

• Creating standoff distance that reduces the effectiveness of vehicle-borne explosive devices
• Channeling pedestrian and vehicular traffic through designated access points
• Preventing unauthorized vehicles from approaching sensitive buildings or infrastructure
• Protecting crowds from both accidental and intentional vehicle incursions

Importantly, bollards contribute to perimeter security without creating fortress-like environments that detract from public spaces. Their relatively small footprint allows for flexible deployment patterns that can accommodate site-specific requirements while maintaining aesthetic appeal. Well-designed public spaces can incorporate these layers of safety while remaining open and welcoming.

Urban Resilience and Perimeter Security in High-Risk Areas

What is urban resilience?

Urban resilience is a city’s ability to adapt and recover from shocks—whether from natural disasters, terrorism, or civil unrest. This concept extends beyond mere survival to include a city’s ability to thrive despite challenges, incorporating forward-thinking strategies that anticipate potential risks. Urban resilience takes a holistic approach that considers physical structures alongside social, economic, and environmental dimensions of urban life.

The core components of urban resilience include:

• Physical infrastructure designed to withstand and recover from impacts
• Social systems that support community cohesion and rapid response
• Economic diversity that prevents collapse during downturns
• Environmental sustainability that preserves natural resources
• Governance structures that facilitate coordination during crises

In the context of social unrest, urban resilience involves creating spaces and systems that can maintain functionality and safety even when challenged by protests, demonstrations, or civil disturbances. 

Planning for Future Unrest: Proactive Strategies

How Cities Can Prepare for Protest Events

Cities can implement comprehensive strategies to prepare for protest events that balance public safety with the protection of First Amendment rights. Developing detailed emergency response plans well before any unrest occurs is essential, ensuring that all city departments can coordinate effectively when protests emerge. These plans should establish clear command structures, communication protocols, and resource allocation procedures to enable rapid deployment when needed.

Training is a critical component of preparation, with law enforcement personnel receiving regular instruction on crowd management tactics, de-escalation techniques, and appropriate use of force. Officers should be equipped with proper protective gear and non-lethal crowd control tools to minimize the risk of injuries during confrontations. 

Proactive engagement with community leaders and potential protest organizers can significantly improve outcomes during demonstrations. By establishing relationships before events occur, authorities can:

• Facilitate communication about planned protests
• Develop mutual understanding about expectations and boundaries
• Create channels for addressing grievances without escalation
• Identify potential flashpoints that might trigger violence

Cities should also conduct thorough risk assessments of potential protest locations, identifying vulnerabilities in infrastructure and developing mitigation strategies. 

Balancing Security and Accessibility in Public Spaces

Designing public spaces that are both secure and welcoming requires integrating safety measures without compromising usability or aesthetics. Government sites, in particular, must reflect democratic openness while ensuring protection from threats like vehicle ramming.

Landscape architecture can help strike this balance by using trees, benches, water features, and grade changes as natural barriers. Architectural elements can also conceal security features within the design, avoiding a fortress-like appearance. Technology supports this integration through unobtrusive screening, intelligent surveillance, intuitive wayfinding, and well-designed lighting.

The key to success lies in embedding security early in the design process and engaging stakeholders—including planners, security experts, and community members—to create spaces that are safe, functional, and inclusive.

Permanent vs. Temporary Barriers

Choosing between permanent and removable barriers depends on the site’s needs. Permanent bollards offer maximum strength and reliability, making them ideal for locations with ongoing security concerns such as government buildings, critical infrastructure, or high-traffic pedestrian zones.

Removable bollards provide flexibility for sites with changing access requirements, such as during events, emergencies, or in areas with historic preservation concerns. Though not as robust as fixed installations, quality removable options can still offer effective deterrence when used appropriately.

Many sites benefit from a hybrid approach—permanent bollards for continuous protection, supplemented with removable or temporary barriers during high-alert periods or special events.

As social unrest continues to pose challenges in cities around the world, proactive strategies and resilient infrastructure become indispensable. Crash-rated bollards offer more than physical protection—they represent a broader commitment to public safety, urban resilience, and the right to gather without fear. By embedding security measures into the built environment, cities can preserve accessibility, protect human life, and maintain functionality even during times of crisis.

FAQs